Wirtschaftsuniversität Wien Logo
  • Show double pages
Use the mouse to select the image area you want to share.
Please select which information should be copied to the clipboard by clicking on the link:
  • Link to the viewer page with highlighted frame
  • Link to IIIF image fragment

Brief von Josef Steindl an Krishna Bharadwaj

InC.Solo.dark

Access restriction

Free access

Copyright

This work is protected by copyright. You can find more informations here.

Bibliographic data

fullscreen: Brief von Josef Steindl an Krishna Bharadwaj

Correspondence

Document type:
Correspondence
Collection:
Josef Steindl Collection
Title:
Brief von Josef Steindl an Krishna Bharadwaj
Author:
Steindl, Josef
Recipient:
Bharadwaj, Krishna
Scope:
Typoskript, 2 Blätter, 2 Seiten sowie 1 Blatt, 2 Seiten mit handschriftlichen Notizen
Place of publication:
Wien
Year of publication:
01/24/1982
Source material date:
Jan. 24, 1982
Language:
English
Shelfmark:
S/B.149
Correspondence partner:
Bharadwaj, Krishna
Steindl, Josef
Use and reproduction license:
In Copyright
Access:
Free access
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.48671/nls.js.1505117019611

Full text

1050 Wien, Schwarzhomgasse 10/17 
Jan.24, 1982. 
ear Krishna, 
I applogize for taking so lang to answer, hut I have been 
working on a few papers and I am very slow nowadays. 
You have written a very beautiful paper on a forbiddingly 
difficult subject. My comments almost entirely refer not to 
your exposition but to its subject - the discussion round Keynes. 
It will not be a secret to you that I have a f eling of deep 
alienation with regard to this discussion. In fact, I can't make 
head and tails of it. Let me mention throe fairly general points* 
1. The discussion at Trieste and what they referred to, are 
almost exclusively turning on Keynes a3 if this were a father figure 
which holds pepple in his grips. If the matter, the problems are 
of interest in the first place, and not the appreciation of depreciation 
of a particular life work, then you would think it natural that 
Kalecki would be included euqually, having the same results as heh;.d 
broadly speaking but different assumptions ( distribution theory! ) 
and a much less ambiguous and more comprehensive system. Equally, 
Keynes' friends Joan R., Kahn al so Harrod could just as well 
I 
contribute to an understanding of what is behind this theory. 
2. What is long run? You come to it fairly late in your paper, on 
p 27 -29. It Appears that it is steady state growth. Strictly 
speaking you jean only compare two such growth systems, which have 
gone on for a very |lo g time and Eire continuing forever! But I 
could hardly jibe too strict about i^t, since Harrod has used the 
method or concept oijf steadiy state growth and 3 have I mylelf in 
i 
Maturity etc. The o! ; ppis±te to it would be process analysis which 
pr ceeds from peri >d to period, and which could also be applied to 
the long run Obvi imsly the steady gr owth is a very abstract concept 
and its basis must Ibe somewhat speculative, certainly much more than 
short run pr cess <|malysis which can more plausibly appeal to facts. 
^ You refer t > peisrmanent characteristics of the system, but are there 
any since the syst em continuously changes? The permanent features are 
either very general ( there is a surplus, but how much? ) or they 
reflect an ideology. 
5. I comldtely fafll to understand how saving which is ( admittedly, 
I suppose) adjusted to investment via the GDP, can be equalised to 
investment (or rarthor, the other way round) by the rate of interest. 
I seems that different concept of savings must be used here (ex ante?)
	        

Downloads

Downloads

Full record

ALTO TEI Full text PDF (compressed) PDF (full size) Mirador

This page

PDF Image Preview Image Small Image Medium Image Large Image Master ALTO TEI Full text Mirador

Image fragment

Link to the viewer page with highlighted frame Link to IIIF image fragment

Formats and links

Formats and links

The metadata is available in various formats. There are also links to external systems.

Formats

METS MARC XML Dublin Core

Links

DFG-Viewer Mirador

Cite

Cite

The following citation links are available for the entire work or the displayed page:

Full record

This page

Citation recommendation

Please check the citation before using it.

Image manipulation tools

Tools not available

Share image region

Use the mouse to select the image area you want to share.
Please select which information should be copied to the clipboard by clicking on the link:
  • Link to the viewer page with highlighted frame
  • Link to IIIF image fragment

Contact

Have you found an error? Do you have any suggestions for making our service even better or any other questions about this page? Please write to us and we'll make sure we get back to you.

What color is the blue sky?:

I hereby confirm the use of my personal data within the context of the enquiry made.