Wirtschaftsuniversität Wien Logo Full screen
  • First image
  • Previous image
  • Next image
  • Last image
  • Show double pages
  • Rotate to the left
  • Rotate to the right
  • Reset image to default view
Use the mouse to select the image area you want to share.
Please select which information should be copied to the clipboard by clicking on the link:
  • Link to the viewer page with highlighted frame
  • Link to IIIF image fragment

Brief von Bertram Schefold an Josef Steindl

Bibliographic data

Correspondence

Document type:
Correspondence
Collection:
Josef Steindl Collection
Title:
Brief von Bertram Schefold an Josef Steindl
Author:
Schefold, Bertram Bharadwaj, Krishna
Recipient:
Steindl, Josef
Scope:
Typoskript mit Unterschrift, 2 Blätter, 2 Seiten
Place of publication:
ohne Ort
Year of publication:
1988-07-26
Source material date:
26. Juli 1988
Language:
German
Shelfmark:
S/B.319
Correspondence partner:
Steindl, Josef Schefold, Bertram Bharadwaj, Krishna
Rights of use:
All rights reserved
Access:
Free access

Supplement

Document type:
Supplement
Title:
Measurement and aggregation: a comment on J. Steindl
Access:
Free access

Contents

Table of contents

  • Brief von Bertram Schefold an Josef Steindl
  • Letter
  • Measurement and aggregation: a comment on J. Steindl

Full text

MEASUREMENT AND AGGREGATION: A COMMENT ON J. STEINDL 
In his paper Professor Steindl raises the question whether macroeconomists should 
be interested in Sraffa’s Standard commodity, ’since measurement and aggregation 
must ultimately be of concern to them’, particularly ’when longer series of data are 
used.’ The answer he gives is in the affirmative: in section 6 of the paper it is 
contended that Sraffa’s concept has meaning ’both for the comparison of one 
economy over time, and for the comparison of entirely different economies’. In this 
brief comment I shall not enter into a discussion of the more technical parts of 
Professor Steindl’s argument and especially his elaboration on the Standard System. I 
shall rather focus attention on some conceptual issues and point out differences 
between Professor Steindl’s reading of Sraffa and mine. 
In my opion the key to a proper understanding of the concept of the Standard 
commodity can be found in an oral intervention of Sraffa’s at the 1958 Corfu 
Conference on the theory of Capital. There Sraffa argued that ‘one should emphasize 
the distinction between two types of measurement. First, there was the one in which 
the statisticians were mainly interested. Second, there was measurement in theory. 
The statistician’s measures were only approximate and provided a suitable field for 
work in solving index number problems. The theoretical measures required absolute 
precision... If we found contradictions, then these pointed to defects in the theory, and 
an unability to define measures of Capital accurately’ (cf. Lutz and Hague, 1961, pp. 
305-306; emphasis added). This distinction appears to be also lurking in the back in 
the following passage taken from Sraffa’s Introduction to Ricardo’s Works: 'The 
search for what has been called "the chimera of an invariable Standard of value" 
preoccupied Ricardo to the end of his life. However, the problem which mainly 
interested him was not that of finding an actual commodity which would accurately 
measure the value of com or silver at different times and places: but rather that of 
finding the conditions which a commodity would have to satisfy in order to be 
invariable in value - and this came close tb identifvina the problem of a measure with 
that of the law of value’ (Sraffa, 1951, pp. xl-xli; emphasis added). Ricardo’s 
unfortunate tendency to confound these two radically different issues caused a lot of 
confusion and turned out to be an obstacle in the way of a proper understanding of 
the role of the Standard commodity in Sraffa’s approach to the theory of value and 
distribution. Indeed, many Interpreters wrongly considered Sraffa’s ingenious concept 
an attempted solution to ’the’ Ricardian problem.
	        

Cite and reuse

Cite and reuse

Here you will find download options and citation links to the record and current image.

Correspondence

METS MARC XML Dublin Core RIS IIIF manifest Mirador ALTO TEI Full text PDF DFG-Viewer OPAC

Supplement

PDF RIS

Image

PDF ALTO TEI Full text
Download

Image fragment

Link to the viewer page with highlighted frame Link to IIIF image fragment

Citation links

Citation links

Correspondence

To quote this record the following variants are available:
Here you can copy a Goobi viewer own URL:

Supplement

To quote this structural element, the following variants are available:
Here you can copy a Goobi viewer own URL:

Image

Here you can copy a Goobi viewer own URL:

Citation recommendation

Schefold, B., & Bharadwaj, K. (1988-07-261988-07-26). Brief von Bertram Schefold an Josef Steindl.
Please check the citation before using it.

Image manipulation tools

Tools not available

Share image region

Use the mouse to select the image area you want to share.
Please select which information should be copied to the clipboard by clicking on the link:
  • Link to the viewer page with highlighted frame
  • Link to IIIF image fragment

Cookies