19
dual semantic theory which claims that we have a formal mode
for determining a terms extension as well as an informal
heuristic mode (Putnam, 1975; Armstrong et al., 1983;
McNamara & Sternberg, 1983). The concept of ownership was
analyzed in terms of plausible attributes or criteria.
Empirical data were sought which might indicate which
criteria were entailed by ownership (Miller, 1978), and to
what degree (Watanabe, 1969; McNamara & Sternberg, 1983).
Empirical data were acquired by two different methods: one
by engaging the subjects in an ownership task in which their
intensional criteria might be implicit and heuristic, and
another by having subjects make explicit formal judgements
as to the definitive worth of criteria in differentiating
owhers from non-owners.
Operationally, the goal was to obtain rank orderings
of the relevance of various criteria of ownership by both
the formal explicit and the informal implicit methods.
Consistent with the exploratory nature of an initial study,
an extensive list of plausible criteria for ownership was
compiled in a relatively atheoretical manner. Following
Cohen's (1954) lead, plausible criteria of amenshis were
whatever explanations or evidence might reasonably be put
forward to support a claim of ownership. From law, for
example, Epstein (1979) discussed ownership by first
possession, by right to destroy, by ownership of self. and